
The Select design this week, Away From Home by Ryan Lin (Kojima) is far and away the best of this batch of Threadless shirts. It's a haunting image, depicting a cold, lonely city and an inviting view of earth looming behind it. To me, this shirt makes me think of the strangeness of space travel and what an odd feeling it must be to miss a place that you can still see outside your window. Gorgeous.

Allan Faustino's Runnin' Rhino was the winner of the PaRappa the Rapper Loves Threadless contest, in which designers came up with shirts that dealt with the theme "I gotta believe!" While this wasn't one of my pet favorites, it is definitely a solid effort. It's easy to feel sorry for the poor rhino, eternally running on the treadmill in the hope of becoming a unicorn one day. It's easily recognizable as a Threadless shirt as well, due to the clean, cartoon-y style (this is the main reason the shirt didn't stand out to me in the contest, so I guess that's a bit of a double-edged sword).
Victor Manuel Moral's Nonsense is a cute take on the idea of holes that go in unlikely directions. It's definitely good work, but what keeps this from being a favorite of mine is the fact that I've seen so many variations on this (my personal favorite was an ostrich). That said, clean simplicity works well on this one, and it'll probably be very popular.

Piggy Bank Heist by Jason LaRose is so classic that I kind of can't believe that the concept hasn't been done already. It just looks like a shirt that Threadless would have, you know? And, as with Nonsense and Runnin' Rhino, it is so cutesy and so similar to the prevailing style of the Threadless catalog that it completely fails to catch my interest. It's not a bad shirt, of course, it's just part of a style that Threadless is over-saturated with.
Joel Cocks' An Elephant Never Forgets... TO KILL! is a shirt that is, to me, completely in the shadow of its fantastic title. A great idea that fails to be a great shirt. Part of the problem here is that the style of the drawing overwhelms the detail work- you'd have to get pretty close to the shirt before you'd see that one character is capturing this image with a cell phone camera (and I think that is the funniest part). The other character's hand isn't rendered very clearly, so I'm just guessing that he's pointing. The elephant looks great, but he's the only visually interesting part of this for me- the man-eating theme of the shirt is just not that nice to look at in comparison, and I feel that the humor element isn't strong enough to overcome that.
Time to Babysit by Scott Ferguson has a great concept. Kids and monsters, how can you go wrong with that? *cough* Well, the style doesn't really appeal to me. The various figures seem lacking in character, and the piece as a whole seems like an attempt to pander to the voters (but hey, it worked!). A lot of people are going to love this one, but I'm not among them. It just feels unfinished somehow.

First reprint this week is Tim Sutcliffe's War and Peas. It's definitely one of Threadless's more famous shirts, and if cutesy designs need to be sold I'd generally prefer that they were sold as reprints, so that more innovative work could be newly printed. Overall, the design is pretty solid- my only issue is that it's a little cheesy to actually have the text "War and Peas" in the scene, particularly when the pun is so obvious.
I'm just going to be totally blunt about Tasty Table by Kenny Wheeler: I think it is a terrible, terrible shirt. Again, you have to get very close to the shirt to even figure out what the text says, and from far away it isn't very good looking- periodic tables have a certain structure to them, and that structure was not built to be eye-pleasing. This would be a great poster, but it is a complete mis-match for the t-shirt medium.
Looking at the week as a whole, I have to say I found this batch to be fairly mediocre. The designs relied on common Threadless styles and concepts instead of stretching and innovating. It's pretty disappointing that the only shirt I'd even consider buying this week is the Select design.
Gmail loves Threadless isn't the only competition that just passed the submission deadline- Parappa the Rapper Loves Threadless just passed its submission deadline as well. Some really great entries were posted, all dealing with the theme of "I Gotta Believe!" Here are my top three:![I Believe [I can fly] - Threadless, Best T-shirts Ever](http://www.threadless.com/subbanner/127249/banner1.png)


I Believe [I can fly] uses fifties-era cartoon styling to create a scene that communicates childhood wishful thinking. It's very charming, and speaks to anyone who was once a child with an impossible dream.
I saw daddy planting a Buddy tree uses a surreal, saturated color palette to great effect. Rather than being a sad scene of a child mourning his dog's death, it almost seems to deal with an alternate reality where a child really can bring his pet back to life with a little hard work and determination (and, of course, a watering can).
Mystic Rain is a bit of an odd one, it depicts a leafy cloud raining leaves on a paisley tree. The color palette is completely fresh, standing out from just about any shirt I've ever seen. And more than any other design in this competition, it looks amazing on a shirt- from composition to color to theme, it is truly made for the t-shirt medium.
Although the Parappa the Rapper competition was often overshadowed by the Gmail contest (they ran concurrently), I think it was actually the more successful of the two. It had more solid entries (in my scoring, anyway) and lacked the sheer volume of designs by untrained and untried designers that marred the Gmail competition. During the Parappa contest, I scored nine designs with 5s (four of which were $5 scores). Of those, none were dropped early and three are still being scored.
Labels: gmail, loves threadless, parappa, threadless

Threadless's new shirt picks for this week are top-notch as usual- and it's an unusually hefty number of new shirts, to boot! Seven awesome, brand new, never before offered shirts and two perfectly reasonable reprints. My favorites of the new crop are Surprise (it makes excellent use of the shirt color and creates a really neat shape on the tee) and Sea-Saw II (a really fun concept executed impeccably).
And for all the shirt designers out there, just a reminder: The Gmail Loves Threadless and PaRappa the Rapper Loves Threadless competitions are currently accepting entries. They both have a deadline of August 16th, 2007.
Labels: gmail, loves threadless, parappa, threadless


This Monday at Threadless is even more hectic than usual: In addition to a great crop of new tees (my favorites, Mother Knows Best and Play, are pictured above) there are also two brand new Loves Threadless competitions!
In the PaRappa the Rapper Loves Threadless competition, designers are encouraged to create shirts with the theme "I Gotta Believe!" In addition to the typical prizes for being printed, the winner will receive a PSP, games and PaRappa merchandise.
The Gmail Loves Threadless competition is going to be insane, I can already tell. The theme is "Connect," which is a pretty easy idea to brainstorm around. And the prizes are nuts! The winner gets an iPhone, a $400 JetBlue gift certificate, a bluetooth headset, and tons of Google merchandise.
Labels: gmail, loves threadless, parappa, threadless

